27454 County Route 57 
Three Mile Bay, NY

$899,900
5 beds
4 full baths
2896 SqFt

For Sale

Schedule a Tour

Choose your date. It's free cancel anytime.

Profile Image
Amanda Miller Lic RE Broker
Licensed RE Broker, Owner
Lake Ontario Realty
  • CHAUMONT, NY
  • Phone: 315-778-1191
  • Office : 315-649-3434
  • Licensed In: NY

27454 County Route 57, Three Mile Bay, NY

Come tour this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own this genuine post and beam Lake Ontario beauty! This over 3,000 square foot gem boasts a total of five bedrooms and four bathrooms which includes a very spacious bunk room above the garage! Stunning views from almost every window in the house, wood floors, beautiful stone fireplace, large open kitchen with eating area and Island plus formal dining room! First floor bedroom and bath, Central vac, attached two-car garage, beautiful Screened in side porch overlooking the bay and so much more! Huge front deck and steps leading down to the shoreline area with another large deck. Over 300 ft of shoreline that is mostly sand in the water and stunning views all tucked away on almost 8 acres of land with solar panels paying your electric bill! Gorgeous fruit orchard throughout the property and so much privacy! This is truly a dream home and a rarity to find! Call today for your private viewing and don't miss out on this beauty!

Property Details
Property Type Residential
Mls # S1559003
LotSize 7.55 acres
Property Subtype Single Family Detached
Year Built 1988
Exterior Types wood siding
Heating Fuels oil
Num Of Floors 2.0
Appliances Refrigerator
Floor Coverings Hardwood, Tile
School District Lyme

When do you plan to buy?
We can help!

Enter your zip code below to get ALL the information in less than 60 Seconds! And download my 'Ultimate Guide to Buying a Home' and get educated about the homebuying process!

What type of property do you plan to buy?

When do you plan to buy?

How would you rate your credit score?

Is this your first property purchase?

How will this property be used?

What is the estimated purchase price of your next home?

$120,000   to   $500,000

What is your estimated down payment?

5% Down

Zero Down

More Than 50% Down

What is your gross annual household income?

$25,000 to $45,000

More Than $250,000

$0 to $25,000

What is your employment status?

Are you working with a real estate agent?

What is your full name and email?

Please enter your full name.
Please enter your Email.
Please enter a valid email address.
or use your Facebook instead
Amanda Miller Lic RE Broker
Amanda Miller Lic RE Broker
Licensed RE Broker, Owner
Lake Ontario Realty
  • CHAUMONT, NY
  • Phone: 315-778-1191
  • Office : 315-649-3434
Thank you

I'll be reaching out to you shortly. In the meantime, please feel free to call or text me with any questions.
Visit me online at http://www.lakeontariorealty.com/

Photos

Get Top Dollar for Your Home

With Our 100+ Point Marketing Plan!

Learn how we will get your home:

  • In front of and shown to more buyers
  • Sold faster and for more money
  • Sold on your terms without the hassle and stress

Real Estate Resource Center

Real Estate Reports for Home Owners, Sellers & Buyers!

Maps & Local

Schools

Print Brochure

Reviews

Google review


12/02/2025 - Kathy A
Google review

Amanda is one of the most helpful, knowledgeable realtors I know. Always willing to offer great guidance and advice.

11/25/2025 - Steve Bradley
Google review

Amanda was fantastic! Not only was she knowledgeable and supportive throughout the entire process, but she also reached out to personal contacts at the bank she recommended to help us move things...
Read more

11/24/2025 - Ashley Hazlewood
Google review


11/24/2025 - Natalie Sparacino
Google review

I bought my first home with Lake Ontario reality!! Kiah was amazing, and our closing was fast and easy! Just 6 weeks to move into our new home! Thank you Amanda and Kiah for the incredible closing...
Read more

11/24/2025 - Lisa Dietterich
Google review


11/24/2025 - Trey Gardner
View more reviews

View More Listings

Click the property below to view the virtual tour of each listing.